Tiers of players?
Tiers of players?
With the Chicago Open coming up, I was wondering about the quality of depth of players. One thing that has weighed on my mind is the thought of tiers of players. I always thought that players are a continuum, and that there are a vast amount of subjects that players know, so it would be hard comparing an Eric Mukherjee to a Matt Jackson. But looking at the recent player polls, people have discussed to death differences between the two and who is better. But I am wondering are there tiers? And if there are, how do we classify players of differing ability?
Peter Cordeiro
McMaster University, 2019 +/-1
Interim President of the ONQBA
Newest Accomplishment: SCT @ Waterloo - Scored over 40PPG on a Full Team
McMaster University, 2019 +/-1
Interim President of the ONQBA
Newest Accomplishment: SCT @ Waterloo - Scored over 40PPG on a Full Team
- Auks Ran Ova
- Forums Staff: Chief Administrator
- Posts: 4295
- Joined: Sun Apr 30, 2006 10:28 pm
- Location: Minneapolis
- Contact:
Re: Tiers of players?
I personally think that Eric Mukherjee is OP and should be nerfed in the next patch.
Rob Carson
University of Minnesota '11, MCTC '??, BHSU forever
Member, ACF
Member emeritus, PACE
Writer and Editor, NAQT
University of Minnesota '11, MCTC '??, BHSU forever
Member, ACF
Member emeritus, PACE
Writer and Editor, NAQT
Re: Tiers of players?
Seth Teitler got all his wins just because of cheap combos that should have been banned from competition tournaments.
Fred Morlan
University of Kentucky CoP, 2017
International Quiz Bowl Tournaments, CEO, co-owner
former PACE member, president, etc.
former hsqbrank manager, former NAQT writer & subject editor, former hsqb Administrator/Chief Administrator
University of Kentucky CoP, 2017
International Quiz Bowl Tournaments, CEO, co-owner
former PACE member, president, etc.
former hsqbrank manager, former NAQT writer & subject editor, former hsqb Administrator/Chief Administrator
Re: Tiers of players?
His final smash wasn't all that great though.Ukonvasara wrote:I personally think that Eric Mukherjee is OP and should be nerfed in the next patch.
Adam Sperber
Hickman '10
Northwestern B '14
Loyola (inactive) '21
" 'Yay, more Adam Sperber' --Nobody " --Cody Voight
Hickman '10
Northwestern B '14
Loyola (inactive) '21
" 'Yay, more Adam Sperber' --Nobody " --Cody Voight
- Auks Ran Ova
- Forums Staff: Chief Administrator
- Posts: 4295
- Joined: Sun Apr 30, 2006 10:28 pm
- Location: Minneapolis
- Contact:
Re: Tiers of players?
Chicago Open 2014: FOX ONLY FINAL DESTINATION NO ITEMSmerv1618 wrote:His final smash wasn't all that great though.Ukonvasara wrote:I personally think that Eric Mukherjee is OP and should be nerfed in the next patch.
Rob Carson
University of Minnesota '11, MCTC '??, BHSU forever
Member, ACF
Member emeritus, PACE
Writer and Editor, NAQT
University of Minnesota '11, MCTC '??, BHSU forever
Member, ACF
Member emeritus, PACE
Writer and Editor, NAQT
- The Ununtiable Twine
- Auron
- Posts: 1058
- Joined: Fri Feb 02, 2007 11:09 pm
- Location: Lafayette, LA
Re: Tiers of players?
Even if we have no choice, is there still a continuum? Are the players well-ordered? What is the cardinality of the set containing quizbowl players?Peter13 wrote:I always thought that players are a continuum, and that there are a vast amount of subjects that players know, so it would be hard comparing an Eric Mukherjee to a Matt Jackson.
Jake Sundberg
Louisiana, Alabama
retired
Louisiana, Alabama
retired
- naan/steak-holding toll
- Auron
- Posts: 2517
- Joined: Mon Feb 28, 2011 11:53 pm
- Location: New York, NY
Re: Tiers of players?
The video game references are pretty funny, but I'll offer a little shot at some serious effort towards this sort of speculation/theory/whatever:
To me, it makes the most sense to group people in tiers of knowledge in particular categories. A generalist can thus be defined as somebody who achieves some minimum tier of knowledge in the majority of categories of questions. These are difficulty-specific, though, and as the difficulty decreases the ability to have lockdown knowledge of any category also decreases due to buzzer races and the limited number of clues in questions.
Basically, the "tiers" of knowledge in a category are essentially arbitrary and depend on two things: How early you can get tossups in that category, and how often you actually get that category of questions against a median team (which is a function of the first thing, as well as miscellaneous things like playing strategy, aggressiveness, etc).
Even within large categories like "history" you still have differential abilities on different subcategories. For example, within history, Mike Cheyne is best at American history, Eric Mukherjee is best at modern and Asian history, and Marshall Steinbaum is best at modern US and European history. I wouldn't call any of these players Tier 1 at the subject - the only people who I think have deep knowledge across most times and places in history are Jeff Hoppes and Matt Bollinger (though Matt Jackson and Jarrett Greene deserve mentions as very well-balanced, and I don't know what Charles Tian really knows, though he knows a lot of things really well).
Quizbowl has so many subcategories and levels of knowledge that it's really hard to make a specific, definitive ranking or formula for valuing players. It's easy to make some general statements (i.e. "Tommy Casalaspi is really good at science, lit, and arts"), individual knowledge of individual question-specific content (i.e. "Ashvin buzzed in the second line of that Hanuman tossup - he must know a lot about that), and even one-vs-one comparisons of knowledge about some subject in the case where it's clear-cut (i.e. "Brian McPeak is better than Chris Manners at science"). It's hard to fit this into an overall hierarchy.
To me, it makes the most sense to group people in tiers of knowledge in particular categories. A generalist can thus be defined as somebody who achieves some minimum tier of knowledge in the majority of categories of questions. These are difficulty-specific, though, and as the difficulty decreases the ability to have lockdown knowledge of any category also decreases due to buzzer races and the limited number of clues in questions.
Basically, the "tiers" of knowledge in a category are essentially arbitrary and depend on two things: How early you can get tossups in that category, and how often you actually get that category of questions against a median team (which is a function of the first thing, as well as miscellaneous things like playing strategy, aggressiveness, etc).
Even within large categories like "history" you still have differential abilities on different subcategories. For example, within history, Mike Cheyne is best at American history, Eric Mukherjee is best at modern and Asian history, and Marshall Steinbaum is best at modern US and European history. I wouldn't call any of these players Tier 1 at the subject - the only people who I think have deep knowledge across most times and places in history are Jeff Hoppes and Matt Bollinger (though Matt Jackson and Jarrett Greene deserve mentions as very well-balanced, and I don't know what Charles Tian really knows, though he knows a lot of things really well).
Quizbowl has so many subcategories and levels of knowledge that it's really hard to make a specific, definitive ranking or formula for valuing players. It's easy to make some general statements (i.e. "Tommy Casalaspi is really good at science, lit, and arts"), individual knowledge of individual question-specific content (i.e. "Ashvin buzzed in the second line of that Hanuman tossup - he must know a lot about that), and even one-vs-one comparisons of knowledge about some subject in the case where it's clear-cut (i.e. "Brian McPeak is better than Chris Manners at science"). It's hard to fit this into an overall hierarchy.
Last edited by naan/steak-holding toll on Thu Jul 17, 2014 12:58 pm, edited 3 times in total.
Will Alston
Dartmouth College '16
Columbia Business School '21
Dartmouth College '16
Columbia Business School '21
Re: Tiers of players?
I'm more of a Pier 1 player.
Mike Cheyne
Formerly U of Minnesota
"You killed HSAPQ"--Matt Bollinger
Formerly U of Minnesota
"You killed HSAPQ"--Matt Bollinger
Re: Tiers of players?
Wombo ComboUkonvasara wrote: Chicago Open 2014: FOX ONLY FINAL DESTINATION NO ITEMS
that ain't Rob Carson
Adam Sperber
Hickman '10
Northwestern B '14
Loyola (inactive) '21
" 'Yay, more Adam Sperber' --Nobody " --Cody Voight
Hickman '10
Northwestern B '14
Loyola (inactive) '21
" 'Yay, more Adam Sperber' --Nobody " --Cody Voight
- Sima Guang Hater
- Auron
- Posts: 1965
- Joined: Mon Feb 05, 2007 1:43 pm
- Location: Nashville, TN
Re: Tiers of players?
That hurts.merv1618 wrote:His final smash wasn't all that great though.Ukonvasara wrote:I personally think that Eric Mukherjee is OP and should be nerfed in the next patch.
Eric Mukherjee, MD PhD
Brown 2009, Penn Med 2018
Instructor/Attending Physician/Postdoctoral Fellow, Vanderbilt University Medical Center
Coach, University School of Nashville
“The next generation will always surpass the previous one. It’s one of the never-ending cycles in life.”
Support the Stevens-Johnson Syndrome Foundation
Brown 2009, Penn Med 2018
Instructor/Attending Physician/Postdoctoral Fellow, Vanderbilt University Medical Center
Coach, University School of Nashville
“The next generation will always surpass the previous one. It’s one of the never-ending cycles in life.”
Support the Stevens-Johnson Syndrome Foundation
Re: Tiers of players?
Done. Eric's team now starts with -50 points every game. We dismissed Gautam and had Nick J. edit all of the bio, who convinced us that it is reasonable to have at least 8/8 questions on savaging. I've replaced all the organic chemistry with alchemy, and all questions on Star Wars, comics and whatever else he's good at have since been converted into questions on " hair products, seasonally-inappropriate clothing, and completing eponyms."Ukonvasara wrote:I personally think that Eric Mukherjee is OP and should be nerfed in the next patch.
Where will the metagame go next?
Ike
UIUC 13
UIUC 13
-
- Wakka
- Posts: 142
- Joined: Mon Mar 26, 2007 5:21 pm
- Location: Ohio
Re: Tiers of players?
Is Joe Flacco elite?
Joseph Wells
Garfield Heights High School '08
Centre College 2008-2010
Tri-C 2010-2011
Ohio State 2011-
Garfield Heights High School '08
Centre College 2008-2010
Tri-C 2010-2011
Ohio State 2011-
Re: Tiers of players?
All joking aside, I will try to give my answer to Will's remark about different categories. While I agree a hierarchy is hard to come by, I certainly see how overall ability, even if completely different specialties (or none in particular) can be compared. But is it arbitrary to just randomly pick a certain point to say when one set of players is better than another? I don't see how it could be for teams, but how about players?
Last edited by Peter13 on Sat Jul 19, 2014 1:40 am, edited 1 time in total.
Peter Cordeiro
McMaster University, 2019 +/-1
Interim President of the ONQBA
Newest Accomplishment: SCT @ Waterloo - Scored over 40PPG on a Full Team
McMaster University, 2019 +/-1
Interim President of the ONQBA
Newest Accomplishment: SCT @ Waterloo - Scored over 40PPG on a Full Team
Re: Tiers of players?
Word on the street is that the Bio questions are being subcontracted to a 4th grader living along the Hoogly river whose parents want him to win the Bournvita Quiz Contest. Unless his name is also Nick J, in which case. It was not clear whether the "Bio" meant "Biology" or "Biography" so I'm pretty sure the kid is writing tossups in Bangla on the Life and Times of Auroni G.Ike wrote:Done. Eric's team now starts with -50 points every game. We dismissed Gautam and had Nick J. edit all of the bio, who convinced us that it is reasonable to have at least 8/8 questions on savaging. I've replaced all the organic chemistry with alchemy, and all questions on Star Wars, comics and whatever else he's good at have since been converted into questions on " hair products, seasonally-inappropriate clothing, and completing eponyms."Ukonvasara wrote:I personally think that Eric Mukherjee is OP and should be nerfed in the next patch.
Where will the metagame go next?
Gautam - ACF
Currently tending to the 'quizbowl hobo' persuasion.
Currently tending to the 'quizbowl hobo' persuasion.
-
- Wakka
- Posts: 188
- Joined: Sat Nov 12, 2011 5:09 pm
Re: Tiers of players?
No. He's like Sam Bradford but with a slightly better final smash. For now I put him half a tier behind Ness or Roethlisberger.powerplant wrote:Is Joe Flacco elite?
Bradley Kirksey
Mayor of quiz bowl at the University of Central Florida (2010-2015)
The club at Reformed Theology Seminary Orlando (2017 - 2021)
Mayor of quiz bowl at the University of Central Florida (2010-2015)
The club at Reformed Theology Seminary Orlando (2017 - 2021)
Re: Tiers of players?
Hey now. We goin' all the way this year.bradleykirksey wrote: He's like Sam Bradford but with a slightly better final smash.
Adam Sperber
Hickman '10
Northwestern B '14
Loyola (inactive) '21
" 'Yay, more Adam Sperber' --Nobody " --Cody Voight
Hickman '10
Northwestern B '14
Loyola (inactive) '21
" 'Yay, more Adam Sperber' --Nobody " --Cody Voight